Skip to content
StippleReal Estate
Talk to an agent

Landlord resources

Source of income and fair chance rules for NYC landlords

In New York City and across New York State, a landlord can't turn away an applicant because of how they lawfully pay their rent, including housing vouchers. NYC also limits when and how you can look at criminal history.

Checked against official sources on November 22, 2026. General information, not legal advice.

What counts as lawful source of income

The NYC Human Rights Law protects any lawful source of income, and New York State's Human Rights Law does the same statewide. The NYC Commission on Human Rights gives examples including Section 8 (Housing Choice Vouchers), CityFHEPS, HASA, Supplemental Security Income (SSI) and GI Bill housing allowances, among others.

You can't refuse to rent, set different terms, or discourage an applicant because of their source of income.

Listings and conversations

  • An ad can't say or suggest that vouchers or rental assistance programs aren't accepted, or express a preference for applicants without a voucher.
  • The same goes for what you or your agents say on the phone, by text or at a showing.
  • Owners are responsible for what their brokers and agents do on their behalf.

Income and credit requirements with vouchers

The Commission's landlord FAQ explains how screening rules apply to applicants with rental assistance:

  • If the tenant's share of the rent is calculated from their income (as with many vouchers), you can't add a separate income requirement, and you can't require a guarantor or co-signer.
  • If a voucher or subsidy covers 100% of the rent, you can't reject the applicant because of their credit history or score.
  • If the tenant pays part of the rent, you may check credit, but requiring a specific credit score is evidence of discrimination.

Penalties

The Commission can award damages to the applicant and impose civil penalties, up to $250,000 for a willful violation, according to its landlord FAQ.

Narrow exemptions

The NYC Commission lists only two exemptions from the city's source of income protection:

  • An apartment in a building with no more than two families, where the owner or a member of their family lives, if the apartment wasn't publicly advertised.
  • A room in an apartment where the owner or a member of their family lives.

Even where an exemption applies, discriminatory ads and statements are still not allowed under New York State law. Once a unit is listed with a broker or advertised, assume the protections apply.

Criminal history: NYC's Fair Chance Housing law

Since January 1, 2025, most NYC housing providers, including owners, managers, brokers and agents, may look at criminal history only after making a conditional offer, and only in the order below. Housing with two or fewer units or rooms, where the provider or their family lives, is exempt.

  1. Step 1: Review everything except criminal history

    Typical time: First

    Decide on the non-criminal parts of the application first, such as ability to pay and references.

  2. Step 2: Make a written conditional offer

    Typical time: Before any check

    For a rental, that means offering the lease. Keep the apartment available while the process runs.

  3. Step 3: Give the Notice of Rights, then run the check

    Typical time: Before the check

    Give the applicant the Fair Chance Housing Notice of Rights before any background check. Only some records may be considered: felonies with a release or sentencing date in the last 5 years, misdemeanors in the last 3 years, and a current sex offense registration. Arrests, pending cases, sealed records, youthful offender adjudications and non-criminal violations can never be considered.

  4. Step 4: If you're thinking of withdrawing the offer

    Typical time: 5 business days

    Give the applicant a copy of everything you received, allow 5 business days for them to respond, do an individualized assessment, and explain any withdrawal in writing. A conviction alone isn't enough to deny housing.

How Stipple handles it

We market every unit to everyone, accept applications from voucher holders on the same terms as anyone else, and screen in the order the law sets out. Our agents give applicants the New York State Housing and Anti-Discrimination Disclosure Form (opens in a new tab), as brokers are required to do.

This page is general information, not legal advice, and it isn't a complete list of an owner's duties. Rules change and individual buildings differ: confirm with the agency linked above or a New York landlord-tenant attorney before you act. Last checked November 22, 2026.