Skip to content
StippleReal Estate
Talk to an agent

In contract

744 Castleton Avenue

Randall Manor · Staten Island, NY 10310

$749,999

Est. $4,480/mo

Listing courtesy of Robert DeFalco Realty, Inc.

Beds
9
Baths
2
Sq ft
3,500

MLS #2606171 · Listing agent Jimmy Samaha

About this home

Rare opportunity in West Brighton Two family on an oversized 91x1278 corner lot (approx. 11648 sq ft.) with a commercial overlay. Offering exceptional potential for an investor, builder or end user. 3 bedrooms plus 3 additional bedrooms on the third level. Gas fireplace. Just steps from Richmond University Medical Center, with bus service right on Castleton Avenue and an easy ride to the St. George Ferry. Close to local schools, Castleton Avenue shops, and the Forest Avenue shopping corridor, with quick access to the Staten Island Expressway and the Verrazano Bridge. Bring your vision: restore it as a spacious two family home or explore the possibilities the commercial overlay allows, such as a professional office or retail use. Needs total renovation. Delivered vacant. Sold as is. Buyers to do their own due diligence on zoning and permitted uses. Do not go on property without a confirmed appointment.

Key facts

Property type
Duplex
Year built
1899
Price / sq ft
$214
Lot size
10,840 sq ft
Taxes / yr
$9,432
Last updated
Nov 15, 2026
MLS #
2606171

Home details

Interior

Bedrooms
9
Bathrooms
2 full
Living area
3,500 sq ft
Basement
Unfinished

Exterior

Style
Colonial
Stories
3
Lot size
10,840 sq ft
Lot dimensions
91x128

Parking

Features
On Street

Utilities, heating and cooling

Heating
Natural Gas, Hot Water
Cooling
None

From the MLS

Interior Details

Architectural Style
Colonial
Basement
Unfinished
Bathrooms Full
2
Bathrooms Half
No
Bathrooms Three Quarter
No
Stories
3

Utilities

Cooling
None; No
Electric
110
Heating
Natural Gas, Hot Water; Yes
Sewer
Public Sewer

Exterior Details

Attached Garage
No
Garage Spaces
No
Lot Size Area
10840
Lot Size Dimensions
91x128
Lot Size Square Feet
10840
Parking Features
On Street

Community Information

Parcel Number
00143-0001
Tax Annual Amount
9432
Zoning
R2

Other Property Information

Listing Id
2606171
New Construction
No
Number Of Units Total
2
Property Sub Type
Duplex
Unit 1 Level
Yes
Unit 1 # Baths
Yes

Monthly payment

$150,000

Loan term

Estimated monthly payment

$4,480/mo

Principal & interest
$3,694
Property taxes
$786

Estimate only, not an offer of credit or a loan quote. Excludes homeowners and mortgage insurance.Taxes use the latest annual amount. Your rate and payment depend on your lender, credit and loan type.

Location

St. GeorgeNew BrightonBrighton HeightsRandall ManorWest BrightonTompkinsvilleWard HillStapletonCliftonConcordRosebankShore AcresGrymes HillSilver LakeSunnysidePort RichmondElm ParkMariner's HarborGranitevilleBloomfieldWesterleighCastleton CornersMeiers CornersEmerson HillGrasmereArrocharSouth BeachOcean BreezeDongan HillsGrant CityMidland BeachNew DorpNew Dorp BeachTodt HillSea ViewLighthouse HillEgbertvilleWillowbrookBulls HeadNew SpringvilleTravis–ChelseaRichmondtownOakwoodOakwood BeachBay TerraceGreat KillsGreenridgeEltingvilleArden HeightsAnnadaleHuguenotPrince's BayWoodrowRossvilleCharlestonRichmond ValleyPleasant PlainsTottenvilleArden WoodsBlood Root ValleyBloomingdale ParkBlue Heron ParkBrookfield ParkClove Lakes ParkConference House ParkFort WadsworthFranklin D. Roosevelt Boardwalk and BeachFreshkills ParkFreshkills Park (North)Freshkills Park (South)Great Kills ParkHigh Rock ParkHoffman & Swinburne IslandsIsle Of MeadowsLaTourette Park & Golf CourseLemon Creek ParkLong Pond ParkMariners Marsh ParkMiller FieldOcean Breeze ParkPralls IslandSaw Mill Creek MarshSilver Lake ParkSnug Harbor Cultural CenterSouth Shore Country ClubStaten Island Industrial ParkWillowbrook ParkWolfe's Pond Park
Randall Manor, Staten Island. Approximate neighborhood borders, not official.

Getting around

Ferry
St. George Ferry Terminal · 1.7 mi
Express buses
SIM30
Local buses
S40, S42, S44, S46, S94, S96

Distances are straight-line from the neighborhood, not this address.

Flood zone

4.1% of tax lots in Randall Manor are in FEMA's 1% annual-chance floodplain (2015 preliminary maps). This is a neighborhood figure; check this address on FEMA's Flood Map Service Center (opens in a new tab).

Schools

Find zoned public schools for this address with the NYC DOE school finder (opens in a new tab).

Read the Randall Manor neighborhood guide

Public records

Staten Island block 143, lot 1 (BBL 5001430001), recorded as 744 CASTLETON AVENUE.

Building class
B2 (Two family, frame)
Land use
One & two family buildings
Lot area
11,648 sq ft
Building area
3,396 sq ft
Floors
2.5
Residential units
2
Year built
1899
Market value (DOF)
$863,000
Assessed value
$51,780
Tax class
1

Assessed value is the part of the market value the Department of Finance taxes, not a sale price.

Source: NYC Open Data, as of Nov 21, 2026.

Public records for information only. Not a consumer report. Compiled by Stipple from New York City and federal open data; not affiliated with or endorsed by the City of New York. Verify anything important with the agency or a professional.

Randall Manor market

Recorded sales from the NYC Department of Finance, rolling 12 months. Medians from fewer than 10 sales are hidden.

Median 1-family sale
$741K
Median price / sq ft
$457
Sales, last 12 months
88
Median lot
4,730 sq ft
1-family median sale price by year
  • Randall Manor
  • All Staten Island
1-family median sale price by year. Randall Manor: $725K in 2025. All Staten Island: $710K in 2025. Use the left and right arrow keys to read each year; a data table follows the chart.$400K$500K$600K$700K$800K201620182020202220242025$725K$710K
View data table
YearRandall ManorAll Staten Island
2016$443,000$437,000
2017$500,000$480,000
2018$530,000$525,000
2019$530,000$530,000
2020$550,000$550,000
2021$610,000$590,000
2022$647,000$639,000
2023$600,000$635,000
2024$640,000$665,000
2025$725,000$710,000
Explore Randall Manor: transit, parks, flood and sales

More homes for sale

Listing courtesy of Robert DeFalco Realty, Inc., (718) 987-7900, broker license #109902939. Listing agent: Jimmy Samaha, license #10301212891. MLS #2606171.

Listing information is provided by the Staten Island Board of REALTORS® MLS. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. Data last updated Nov 20, 2026, 10:51 PM ET.

Stipple, Inc. is not the listing broker for this home. If you ask about it, a Stipple agent can represent you as the buyer's agent.

Stipple, Inc. is a licensed real estate broker in New York. New York State Fair Housing Notice (opens in a new tab) · NYS Housing and Anti-Discrimination Disclosure (opens in a new tab) · Standard Operating Procedures.

Equal Housing Opportunity