South Shore · Staten Island
Pleasant Plains
Mount Loretto's bluffs and the 1864 Prince's Bay Light on Raritan Bay, with a small commercial center at Amboy and Bloomingdale Roads.

Pleasant Plains at a glance
- 1-family median sale
- $770K
- 31 sales · Staten Island $720K
- 2-family median sale
- —
- 8 sales · Staten Island $945K
- Condo median sale
- —
- 0 sales
- Typical lot (sold homes)
- 5,860 sq ft
- Nearest station
- 0.1 mi
- Pleasant Plains (SIR)
- Train to the ferry
- 29 min
- Scheduled SIR time to St. George
- Express bus routes nearby
- 3
- SIM2, SIM25, SIM26
- Lots in FEMA 1% floodplain
- 4.9%
- Wider area · 2015 preliminary map
Sales: NYC Department of Finance, October 2025 – September 2026, sales over $10,000 recorded under Pleasant Plains; medians from fewer than 10 sales are hidden. Transit: MTA and ferry schedules, distances from the neighborhood center. Flood and Census figures cover the wider area (Annadale-Huguenot-Prince's Bay-Woodrow). About this data
Overview
Living in Pleasant Plains
Pleasant Plains grew up around the railway station its owners named when the line reached Tottenville in 1860. The small commercial center is at Bloomingdale Road, Amboy Road and Pleasant Plains Avenue, near the station.
South of Hylan Boulevard, the Mount Loretto Unique Area runs down to Raritan Bay. Managed by the state Department of Environmental Conservation, it has grasslands, wetlands and red clay bluffs, with the Prince's Bay Light standing on the highest point. Lemon Creek Park adjoins it on the east.
Mount Loretto Unique Area
State-managed grasslands, wetlands and shoreline bluffs on Raritan Bay.
Prince's Bay Light
Lighthouse built in 1864 on the highest bluff at Mount Loretto, with a keeper's cottage added in 1868.
Lemon Creek Park
NYC Parks land adjoining Mount Loretto, partly in Pleasant Plains.
Pleasant Plains station
Staten Island Railway stop near Amboy and Bloomingdale Roads.
What you'll pay
Home prices
- Pleasant Plains
- All Staten Island
View data table
| Year | Pleasant Plains | All Staten Island |
|---|---|---|
| 2016 | $532,000 | $437,000 |
| 2017 | $510,000 | $480,000 |
| 2018 | $576,000 | $525,000 |
| 2019 | $710,000 | $530,000 |
| 2020 | $620,000 | $550,000 |
| 2021 | $690,000 | $590,000 |
| 2022 | $683,000 | $639,000 |
| 2023 | $760,000 | $635,000 |
| 2024 | $758,000 | $665,000 |
| 2025 | $797,000 | $710,000 |
1-family
$770K
31 sales · $573/sq ft
2-family
—
8 sales
3-family
—
1 sales
Condo
—
0 sales
Co-op
—
0 sales
Last 12 months: October 2025 – September 2026. 40 residential sales recorded; median year built of homes sold: 1965.
What you'll find
Homes & streets
Housing is mostly detached houses, older ones near the station and Amboy Road and newer ones in late-20th- and 21st-century developments, including houses built on a former convent tract at Mount Loretto's northeastern corner.
- Single-family68%
- 2–4 units32%
- 5+ units1%
- Other0%
- Owner-occupied homes
- 76%
- Built before 1940
- 6%
- Built since 2000
- 27%
U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2020–2024, aggregated from census tracts.
Getting around
Commute & transit
Pleasant Plains station on the Staten Island Railway runs north to St. George and the ferry. The S55 runs along Amboy and Bloomingdale Roads, the SIM26 express bus connects to Manhattan, and the Korean War Veterans Parkway and West Shore Expressway are nearby.
- Pleasant PlainsSIR0.1 mi
- Richmond ValleySIR0.6 mi
- Prince's BaySIR1.0 mi
Getting to Lower Manhattan by ferry
About 29 min on the Staten Island Railway from Pleasant Plains to St. George, then the free Staten Island Ferry (about 25 minutes) to Whitehall Terminal. Add walking time and waits; schedules vary by time of day.
Express buses: SIM2, SIM25, SIM26. Local buses: S55.
- Average commute
- 44 min
- Commute by transit
- 15%
- Commutes over 60 min
- 33%
- Households without a car
- 7%
Stations within 1 mile, local buses with a stop within ½ mile and express buses within ¾ mile of the neighborhood center (MTA GTFS). Commute figures: ACS 2020–2024 for the wider area.
Parks & places
Outdoors & everyday life
- Parks within ¾ mile
- 5
- Their total acres
- 660
- Libraries within 1½ miles
- 1
- Public K–12 schools within ¾ mile
- 1
- Richmond Parkway351 acres · 0.4 mi
- Bloomingdale Park138 acres · 0.5 mi
- Long Pond Park91 acres · 0.5 mi
- Fairview Park43 acres · 0.7 mi
- Meredith Woods37 acres · 0.3 mi
Beaches: Wolfes Pond Beach (1.4 mi). Libraries: Charleston Library (1.0 mi).
NYC Parks Properties and beaches, NYC Facilities Database. School counts are for reference only; for school information see the NYC Public Schools school finder.
Flood & resilience
Flood risk, in plain numbers
- Lots in the 1% annual-chance floodplain (2015 preliminary FEMA map)
- 4.9%
- Lots in the 1% floodplain (2007 effective FEMA map)
- 4.8%
Staten Island has a long coastline, and Hurricane Sandy in 2012 flooded large parts of the East and South Shores. Before you buy or rent, look up the specific address on FEMA's Flood Map Service Center and on the NYC Flood Hazard Mapper, which shows FEMA's effective maps alongside the preliminary maps the city uses for some building rules. If a building with a federally backed mortgage sits in a FEMA high-risk zone (a Special Flood Hazard Area), the lender will require flood insurance; outside those zones it is optional but often worth pricing, since many flood claims come from lower-risk areas. New York also requires disclosure. Since March 20, 2024, sellers of most residential property must complete the state's Property Condition Disclosure Statement, which now includes questions about whether the property is in a FEMA floodplain, has flood insurance or has had flood damage claims or FEMA assistance (the old $500 credit in lieu of the form was eliminated). Since June 21, 2023, landlords must include a flood history and risk notice in residential leases under Real Property Law §231-b, stating whether the property is in a FEMA floodplain and whether it has had flood damage, and noting that renters' insurance generally does not cover flood losses. Our neighborhood pages show the share of lots in the mapped floodplain as a starting point, not a substitute for a lot-level check.
NYC Flood Hazard MapperFloodHelpNY address lookupFEMA Flood Map Service Center
Share of 12,832 tax lots in the wider area (Annadale-Huguenot-Prince's Bay-Woodrow) flagged in NYC PLUTO. A flag means part of the lot is in the mapped floodplain, not that the building floods.
Honest trade-offs
The downside
- The ferry is a long railway ride away at St. George.
- Shopping is limited to a few blocks around the station; larger stores are a drive away.
- Shoreline areas near Raritan Bay and Lemon Creek are in mapped flood zones.
History
How it got here
In 1882, the Reverend John Christopher Drumgoole bought a farm here and built Mount Loretto, which became one of the largest orphanages in New York State. The state bought the shoreline land in 1999 and opened it as a nature preserve.
FAQ
Pleasant Plains questions
Can you visit Mount Loretto?
Yes. The Mount Loretto Unique Area is state land managed by the Department of Environmental Conservation, open to the public, with views from the bluffs over Raritan Bay.
Is Pleasant Plains in a flood zone?
Areas near the bay and Lemon Creek are; much of the neighborhood sits higher. Check the specific address on FEMA's Flood Map Service Center and the NYC Flood Hazard Mapper, which show both current and preliminary flood zones. Zone lines can split a block, so a lot-level check (and, for a purchase, an elevation certificate) is the only reliable answer.
Sources
About this data
- 2020 Neighborhood Tabulation Areas (NTAs) · Department of City Planning (DCP) · Updated 2026-11-02
- 2020 Census Tracts to 2020 NTAs Equivalency · Department of City Planning (DCP) · Updated 2021-09-20
- Citywide Rolling Calendar Sales · Department of Finance · Updated 2026-10-15
- Citywide Annualized Calendar Sales (trend and neighborhood points) · Department of Finance · Updated 2026-06-09
- Primary Land Use Tax Lot Output (PLUTO) · Department of City Planning (DCP) · Updated 2026-08-24
- Parks Properties · Department of Parks and Recreation (DPR) · Updated 2026-10-16
- Beaches · Department of Parks and Recreation (DPR) · Updated 2026-10-15
- Facilities Database · Department of City Planning (DCP) · Updated 2026-07-16
- American Community Survey 5-year estimates (tables B25003, B25024, B25034, B08013, B08303, B08301, B25044) · U.S. Census Bureau · 2020–2024 ACS 5-year
- MTA GTFS static feed: subway and Staten Island Railway · Metropolitan Transportation Authority · Schedule from 2026-11-01
- MTA GTFS static feed: Staten Island buses · Metropolitan Transportation Authority · Schedule from 2026-10-12
Neighborhood sales use Department of Finance neighborhood names; Census, flood and area figures use NYC Department of City Planning 2020 Neighborhood Tabulation Areas, because no official boundaries exist below that level. Stipple is committed to fair housing: these guides describe places, homes, prices and access, never the people who live there, and every neighborhood gets the same data. Figures are estimates from public sources and may contain errors; verify details for any specific property.
Editorial sources: en.wikipedia.org, en.wikipedia.org, dec.ny.gov, en.wikipedia.org.
Neighborhoods
Talk to a local agent
Tell us what you're looking for. A licensed Stipple agent will share homes that fit, and we'll let you know when new listings go live in the neighborhoods you pick.
Prefer to call? 718.333.5499