Skip to content
StippleReal Estate

South Shore · Staten Island

Tottenville

The southern tip of New York State: the 17th-century Conference House at Ward's Point, Main Street's older blocks and the railway's last stop.

St. George-New BrightonTompkinsville-Stapleton-Clifton-Fox HillsRosebank-Shore Acres-Park HillWest New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes HillWesterleigh-Castleton CornersPort RichmondMariner's Harbor-Arlington-GranitevilleGrasmere-Arrochar-South Beach-Dongan HillsNew Dorp-Midland BeachTodt Hill-Emerson Hill-Lighthouse Hill-Manor HeightsNew Springville-Willowbrook-Bulls Head-TravisOakwood-RichmondtownGreat Kills-EltingvilleArden Heights-RossvilleAnnadale-Huguenot-Prince's Bay-WoodrowTottenville-CharlestonSt. GeorgeNew BrightonTompkinsvilleStapletonCliftonConcordRosebankGrymes HillSilver LakeSunnysideClove LakesWest New BrightonLivingstonPort RichmondMariners HarborWesterleighCastleton CornersGrasmereArrocharSouth BeachOld TownDongan HillsGrant CityMidland BeachNew DorpNew Dorp BeachTodt HillEmerson HillManor HeightsLighthouse HillWillowbrookBulls HeadNew SpringvilleTravisRichmondtownOakwoodBay TerraceGreat KillsEltingvilleArden HeightsAnnadaleHuguenotPrince's BayWoodrowRossvilleCharlestonRichmond ValleyPleasant PlainsTottenville
Small boats and old pilings on the Arthur Kill at Tottenville, with the Outerbridge Crossing in the distance
Photo: Jim.henderson · Public domain

Tottenville at a glance

1-family median sale
$875K
70 sales · Staten Island $720K
2-family median sale
$1.25M
61 sales · Staten Island $945K
Condo median sale
—
3 sales
Typical lot (sold homes)
5,000 sq ft
Nearest station
0.6 mi
Arthur Kill (SIR)
Train to the ferry
33 min
Scheduled SIR time to St. George
Express bus routes nearby
3
SIM2, SIM25, SIM26
Lots in FEMA 1% floodplain
9.8%
Wider area · 2015 preliminary map

Sales: NYC Department of Finance, October 2025 – September 2026, sales over $10,000 recorded under Tottenville; medians from fewer than 10 sales are hidden. Transit: MTA and ferry schedules, distances from the neighborhood center. Flood and Census figures cover the wider area (Tottenville-Charleston). About this data

Overview

Living in Tottenville

Tottenville is surrounded by water on three sides, with the Arthur Kill to the west and north and Raritan Bay to the south. Main Street, the historic commercial corridor, runs inland from the water, and the side streets hold a long run of 19th-century frame houses.

Conference House Park covers the southern tip at Ward's Point, the southernmost point in New York State, around the stone Conference House. The Staten Island Railway ends at Tottenville station near the water, and the newer Arthur Kill station sits to the north on Arthur Kill Road.

  • Conference House

    Stone manor house built by Christopher Billop before about 1680, site of the failed peace conference of September 11, 1776.

  • Conference House Park

    Waterfront park at Ward's Point, the southernmost point in New York State.

  • Tottenville Library

    A 1904 Carnegie library and a city landmark.

  • Main Street

    The neighborhood's historic commercial corridor.

What you'll pay

Home prices

Median prices from recorded Department of Finance sales. Medians move with the mix of homes that sell each year; ask an agent for a home-specific valuation.
1-family median sale price by year
  • Tottenville
  • All Staten Island
1-family median sale price by year. Tottenville: $763K in 2025. All Staten Island: $710K in 2025. Use the left and right arrow keys to read each year; a data table follows the chart.$400K$500K$600K$700K$800K201620182020202220242025$763K$710K
View data table
YearTottenvilleAll Staten Island
2016$470,000$437,000
2017$545,000$480,000
2018$600,000$525,000
2019$575,000$530,000
2020$586,000$550,000
2021$648,000$590,000
2022$725,000$639,000
2023$640,000$635,000
2024$716,000$665,000
2025$763,000$710,000

1-family

$875K

70 sales · $469/sq ft

2-family

$1.25M

61 sales · $432/sq ft

3-family

—

1 sales

Condo

—

3 sales

Co-op

—

0 sales

Last 12 months: October 2025 – September 2026. 135 residential sales recorded; median year built of homes sold: 1989.

What you'll find

Homes & streets

Census figures cover the wider area: Tottenville-Charleston.

Tottenville has some of the island's oldest surviving houses: 19th- and early-20th-century frame houses near Main Street and the water. Southeast of Hylan Boulevard, many detached houses date from a building wave in the 1990s.

Housing by building type (wider area)
  • Single-family70%
  • 2–4 units24%
  • 5+ units6%
  • Other0%
Owner-occupied homes
81%
Built before 1940
23%
Built since 2000
28%

U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2020–2024, aggregated from census tracts.

Getting around

Commute & transit

Tottenville station, the southernmost railway station in New York State, and Arthur Kill station (opened 2017, with a parking lot) are the last stops on the Staten Island Railway to St. George. Express buses run to Manhattan, and the Outerbridge Crossing is close.

  • Arthur KillSIR0.6 mi
  • TottenvilleSIR0.7 mi

Getting to Lower Manhattan by ferry

About 33 min on the Staten Island Railway from Arthur Kill to St. George, then the free Staten Island Ferry (about 25 minutes) to Whitehall Terminal. Add walking time and waits; schedules vary by time of day.

Express buses: SIM2, SIM25, SIM26. Local buses: S59, S74, S78.

Average commute
40 min
Commute by transit
10%
Commutes over 60 min
21%
Households without a car
7%

Stations within 1 mile, local buses with a stop within ½ mile and express buses within ¾ mile of the neighborhood center (MTA GTFS). Commute figures: ACS 2020–2024 for the wider area.

Parks & places

Outdoors & everyday life

Parks within ¾ mile
6
Their total acres
401
Libraries within 1½ miles
1
Public K–12 schools within ¾ mile
3
  • Conference House ParkWaterfront287 acres · 0.5 mi
  • Long Pond Park91 acres · 0.6 mi
  • Hybrid Oak Woods Park10 acres · 0.4 mi
  • Tottenville Shore ParkWaterfront9 acres · 0.6 mi
  • Tottenville Pool3 acres · 0.3 mi
  • Aesop Park1 acres · 0.6 mi

Libraries: Tottenville Library (0.2 mi).

NYC Parks Properties and beaches, NYC Facilities Database. School counts are for reference only; for school information see the NYC Public Schools school finder.

Flood & resilience

Flood risk, in plain numbers

Check any specific address on the NYC Flood Hazard Mapper before you buy or rent.
Lots in the 1% annual-chance floodplain (2015 preliminary FEMA map)
9.8%
Lots in the 1% floodplain (2007 effective FEMA map)
5.5%

Staten Island has a long coastline, and Hurricane Sandy in 2012 flooded large parts of the East and South Shores. Before you buy or rent, look up the specific address on FEMA's Flood Map Service Center and on the NYC Flood Hazard Mapper, which shows FEMA's effective maps alongside the preliminary maps the city uses for some building rules. If a building with a federally backed mortgage sits in a FEMA high-risk zone (a Special Flood Hazard Area), the lender will require flood insurance; outside those zones it is optional but often worth pricing, since many flood claims come from lower-risk areas. New York also requires disclosure. Since March 20, 2024, sellers of most residential property must complete the state's Property Condition Disclosure Statement, which now includes questions about whether the property is in a FEMA floodplain, has flood insurance or has had flood damage claims or FEMA assistance (the old $500 credit in lieu of the form was eliminated). Since June 21, 2023, landlords must include a flood history and risk notice in residential leases under Real Property Law §231-b, stating whether the property is in a FEMA floodplain and whether it has had flood damage, and noting that renters' insurance generally does not cover flood losses. Our neighborhood pages show the share of lots in the mapped floodplain as a starting point, not a substitute for a lot-level check.

NYC Flood Hazard MapperFloodHelpNY address lookupFEMA Flood Map Service Center

Share of 6,225 tax lots in the wider area (Tottenville-Charleston) flagged in NYC PLUTO. A flag means part of the lot is in the mapped floodplain, not that the building floods.

Honest trade-offs

The downside

  • The longest trip to the ferry on the island: the railway runs the full length of Staten Island.
  • Shoreline blocks along the Arthur Kill and Raritan Bay are low-lying and in mapped flood zones.
  • Retail is limited to Main Street and a few strips; bigger stores mean a drive to Charleston.

History

How it got here

Christopher Billop named the settlement Bentley Manor after his ship; it was renamed Tottenville in 1869, apparently after the local Totten family. A ferry crossed the Arthur Kill to Perth Amboy until 1963, declining after the Outerbridge Crossing opened in 1928.

FAQ

Tottenville questions

What happened at the Conference House?

On September 11, 1776, Benjamin Franklin, John Adams and Edward Rutledge met Admiral Lord Richard Howe there in an unsuccessful attempt to end the Revolutionary War. The house is now a museum in Conference House Park.

Is Tottenville in a flood zone?

Parts near the Arthur Kill and Raritan Bay are; inland blocks sit higher. Check the specific address on FEMA's Flood Map Service Center and the NYC Flood Hazard Mapper, which show both current and preliminary flood zones. Zone lines can split a block, so a lot-level check (and, for a purchase, an elevation certificate) is the only reliable answer.

Sources

About this data

Neighborhood sales use Department of Finance neighborhood names; Census, flood and area figures use NYC Department of City Planning 2020 Neighborhood Tabulation Areas, because no official boundaries exist below that level. Stipple is committed to fair housing: these guides describe places, homes, prices and access, never the people who live there, and every neighborhood gets the same data. Figures are estimates from public sources and may contain errors; verify details for any specific property.

Editorial sources: en.wikipedia.org, en.wikipedia.org, nycgovparks.org, en.wikipedia.org, en.wikipedia.org.

Neighborhoods

Talk to a local agent

Tell us what you're looking for. A licensed Stipple agent will share homes that fit, and we'll let you know when new listings go live in the neighborhoods you pick.

All fields are required unless marked optional.

We use your information only to respond to your inquiry. See our Privacy Policy.

Prefer to call? 718.333.5499